Malaria remains a worldwide threat, afflicting over 200 million people each year. The emergence of drug resistance against existing therapeutics threatens to destabilize global efforts aimed at controlling Plasmodium spp. parasites, which is expected to leave vast portions of humanity unprotected against the disease. To address this need, systematic testing of a fungal natural product extract library assembled through the University of Oklahoma Citizen Science Soil Collection Program has generated an initial set of bioactive extracts that exhibit potent antiplasmodial activity (EC50 < 0.30 μg/mL) and low levels of toxicity against human cells (less than 50% reduction in HepG2 growth at 25 μg/mL). Analysis of the two top-performing extracts from Trichoderma sp. and Hypocrea sp. isolates revealed both contained chemically diverse assemblages of putative peptaibol-like compounds that were responsible for their antiplasmodial actions. Purification and structure determination efforts yielded 30 new peptaibols and lipopeptaibols (1-14 and 28-43), along with 22 known metabolites (15-27 and 44-52). While several compounds displayed promising activity profiles, one of the new metabolites, harzianin NPDG I (14), stood out from the others due to its noteworthy potency (EC50 = 0.10 μM against multi-drug-resistant P. falciparum line Dd2) and absence of gross toxicity toward HepG2 at the highest concentrations tested (HepG2 EC50 > 25 μM, selectivity index > 250). The unique chemodiversity afforded by these fungal isolates serves to unlock new opportunities for translating peptaibols into a bioactive scaffold worthy of further development.