Cholestatic liver injury is frequently associated with drug inhibition of bile salt transporters, such as the bile salt export pump (BSEP). Reliable in silico models to predict BSEP inhibition directly from chemical structures would significantly reduce costs during drug discovery and could help avoid injury to patients. We report our development of classification and regression models for BSEP inhibition with substantially improved performance over previously published models. We assessed the performance effects of different methods of chemical featurization, data set partitioning, and class labeling and identified the methods producing models that generalized best to novel chemical entities.