Accuracy of 3-dimensional printing of dental casts: A proposal for quality standardization

Abstract

Statement of problem: A digital workflow in fixed prosthodontics may use a 3D printer to obtain a cast for porcelain application. Standards exist that define the accuracy of traditional casts, but the accuracy requirements of 3D-printed casts have not been defined.

Purpose: The purpose of this retrospective study was to investigate how the accuracy of 3D-printed casts affected prosthesis fit and whether they correctly reproduced interproximal contacts.

Material and methods: Copings with different die spacings were used to test different 3D-printed casts of the same dental arch. The accuracy of the 3D casts was assessed by imaging and comparing the resulting standard tessellation language (STL) files with the original through a matching software program. Accuracy scores were then correlated with a score measuring how well the copings fit the casts. The first data set was obtained from a patient receiving restoration of the 4 maxillary incisors. The teeth were prepared, the dental arch was imaged intraorally, and 10 resin casts were printed with four 3D printers. Two sets of 4 zirconia test copings were prepared, and 3 clinicians assessed their fit on each cast. A further set of casts was created from a second patient requiring prosthetic restoration for 5 adjacent teeth to assess whether undersizing affected the best fit of the copings on their dies.

Results: The clinical scores and accuracy scores did not correlate. The results suggested that printed dies showing a certain degree of undersizing might provide a better fit than those showing better correspondence to the actual anatomic structure. The oversized dies were the worst. Only 7 of 17 casts being assessed were deemed suitable for veneering of the copings. The undersized casts tested clinically better than casts printed by using the same printer under standard settings.

Conclusions: This retrospective study indicated that 3D-printed casts that do not allow copings to fit appropriately usually show mean excess oversizing. Axially undersizing the printed dies on casts might allow a better fit of copings to be veneered.