Conventional electrical-field-assisted sample preparation (EFASP) methods rely on analyte transfer between immiscible phases and require at least one aqueous phase in contact with the electrode. In this paper, we report a novel nonaqueous miscible liquid-liquid electroextraction (NMLEE) technique that enables fast exhaustive enrichment of ultratrace analytes from a milliliter-level donor in a vial to a microliter-level acceptor in a tube. Miscible nonaqueous solvents are used for the donor and acceptor to overcome common EFASP problems such as high charge or mass transfer resistance, loss of analytes in the membrane phase, water electrolysis, back-extraction, bubble generation, and difficulties in the application of high voltage for fast migration. According to theoretical derivation and experimental verification results, the concentrations of analytes in the donor and their migration velocity in the acceptor both decrease exponentially with time, and the extraction recovery correlates linearly with the current variation. These mechanisms result in efficient enrichment by forming an analyte-enriched zone and allow the extraction progress and recovery to be monitored and estimated based on the current variation. NMLEE was coupled with liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry to analyze 10 amphetamine-type drugs, atropine, nortriptyline, and methadone in blood and urine samples. This method provided low limits of detection (0.003-0.1 ng·mL-1), satisfactory extraction recoveries (89.6-104.1%), and RSDs (<12.3% for intraday and <8.8% for interday), which met the requirements of the ICH guidelines. This study may contribute to the further development of EFASP methods for effective ultratrace analyses in forensic science.