Iron-driven secondary brown carbon formation reactions from water-soluble organics in cloud droplets and aerosols create insoluble and soluble products of emerging atmospheric importance. This work shows, for the first time, results on dark iron-catalyzed polymerization of catechol forming insoluble black polycatechol particles and colored water-soluble oligomers under conditions characteristic of viscous multicomponent aerosol systems with relatively high ionic strength (I = 1-12 m) and acidic pH (∼2). These systems contain ammonium sulfate (AS)/nitrate (AN) and C3-C5 dicarboxylic acids, namely, malonic, malic, succinic, and glutaric acids. Using dynamic light scattering (DLS) and ultra high pressure liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (UHPLC-MS), we show results on the rate of particle growth/agglomeration and identity of soluble oligomeric reaction products. We found that increasing I above 1 m and adding diacids with oxygen-to-carbon molar ratio (O:C > 1) significantly reduced the rate of polycatechol formation/aggregation by a factor of 1.3 ± 0.4 in AS solution in the first 60 min of reaction time. Using AN, rates were too slow to be quantified using DLS, but particles formed after 24 h reaction time. These results were explained by the relative concentration and affinity of ligands to Fe(III). We also report detectable amounts of soluble and colored oligomers in reactions with a slow rate of polycatechol formation, including organonitrogen compounds. These results highlight that brown carbon formation from iron chemistry is efficient under a wide range of aerosol physical states and chemical composition.