Urine dipsticks are not accurate for detecting mild ketosis during a severely energy restricted diet

Alice A Gibson; Elif I Eroglu; Kieron Rooney; Claudia Harper; Sally McClintock; Janet Franklin; Tania P Markovic; Radhika V Seimon; Amanda Sainsbury

doi:10.1002/osp4.432

Urine dipsticks are not accurate for detecting mild ketosis during a severely energy restricted diet

Obes Sci Pract. 2020 Jun 10;6(5):544-551. doi: 10.1002/osp4.432. eCollection 2020 Oct.

Authors

Affiliations

¹ Boden Collaboration for Obesity, Nutrition, Exercise and Eating Disorders, Faculty of Medicine and Health The University of Sydney Camperdown New South Wales Australia.
² The Menzies Centre for Health Policy, School of Public Health, Faculty of Medicine and Health The University of Sydney Camperdown New South Wales Australia.
³ Discipline of Exercise and Sport Science, Faculty of Medicine and Health, Charles Perkins Centre University of Sydney Sydney New South Wales Australia.
⁴ Metabolism & Obesity Services Royal Prince Alfred Hospital Camperdown New South Wales Australia.
⁵ School of Human Sciences, Faculty of Science The University of Western Australia Crawley Western Australia Australia.

Abstract

Background: Detection of the mild ketosis induced by severely energy-restricted diets may be a clinically useful way to monitor and promote dietary adherence. Mild ketosis is often assessed using urine dipsticks, but accuracy for this purpose has not been tested.

Objective: To determine the accuracy of urine dipsticks to detect mild ketosis during adherence to a severely energy-restricted diet.

Methods: Two hundred and sixty three (263) fasting urine and 263 fasting blood samples were taken from 50 women (mean [standard deviation, SD] age 58.0 [4.3] years and body mass index 34.3 [2.4] kg/m²) before and at six time points during or for up to 10 weeks after 16 weeks of severe energy restriction, achieved with a total meal replacement diet. The amount of ketones (acetoacetate) in the urine was classified as '0 (Negative)', '+/- (Trace)', '+ (Weak)' or '++ (Medium)' by urine dipsticks (Ketostix, Bayer). The concentration of ketones (β-hydroxybutyrate) in the blood was measured with our reference method, a portable ketone monitor (FreeStyle Optium, Abbott). The diagnostic accuracy of the urine dipsticks was assessed from the percent of instances when a person was actually 'in ketosis' (as defined by a blood β-hydroxybutyrate concentration at or above three different thresholds) that were also identified by the urine dipsticks as being from a person in ketosis (the percent 'true positives' or sensitivity), as well as the percent of instances when a person was not in ketosis (as defined by the blood monitor result) was correctly identified as such with the urine dipstick (the percent 'true negatives' or specificity). Thresholds of ≥0.3mM, ≥0.5mM or ≥1.0mM were selected, because mean blood concentrations of β-hydroxybutyrate during ketogenic diets are approximately 0.5mM. Sensitivity and specificity were then used to generate receiver operating characteristic curves, with the area under these curves indicating the ability of the dipsticks to correctly identify people in ketosis (1 = perfect results, 0.5 = random results).

Results: At threshold blood β-hydroxybutyrate concentrations of ≥0.3mM, ≥0.5mM and ≥1.0mM, the sensitivity of the urine dipsticks was 35%, 52% and 76%; the specificity was 100%, 97% and 78%; and the area under the receiver operating characteristic curves was 0.67, 0.74 and 0.77, respectively. These low levels of sensitivity mean that 65%, 48% or 24% of the instances when a person was in ketosis were not detected by the urine dipsticks.

Conclusion: Urine dipsticks are not an accurate or clinically useful means of detecting mild ketosis in people undergoing a severely energy-restricted diet and should thus not be recommended in clinical treatment protocols. If monitoring of mild ketosis is indicated (eg, to monitor or help promote adherence to a severely energy-restricted diet), then blood monitors should be used instead.

Keywords: ketogenic diet; meal replacement; very low calorie diet; very low energy diet.