The diagnostic evaluation and clinical characterization of rare hereditary anemia (RHA) is to date still challenging. In particular, there is little knowledge on the broad metabolic impact of many of the molecular defects underlying RHA. In this study we explored the potential of untargeted metabolomics to diagnose a relatively common type of RHA: Pyruvate Kinase Deficiency (PKD). In total, 1903 unique metabolite features were identified in dried blood spot samples from 16 PKD patients and 32 healthy controls. A metabolic fingerprint was identified using a machine learning algorithm, and subsequently a binary classification model was designed. The model showed high performance characteristics (AUC 0.990, 95%CI 0.981-0.999) and an accurate class assignment was achieved for all newly added control (13) and patient samples (6), with the exception of one patient (accuracy 94%). Important metabolites in the metabolic fingerprint included glycolytic intermediates, polyamines and several acyl carnitines. In general, the application of untargeted metabolomics in dried blood spots is a novel functional tool that holds promise for diagnostic stratification and studies on disease pathophysiology in RHA.