Communication skills training using virtual reality: A descriptive qualitative study

Abstract

Background: Modern medical pedagogical strategies are shifting toward the use of virtual patient simulations.

Objective: This study aims to examine students' users' attitudes and experiences and clinical facilitators' perspectives on student performances in the clinical setting post-virtual patient training.

Design: A descriptive qualitative study design was used.

Setting: Nursing faculty at a local university in Singapore.

Participants: 24 nursing undergraduates and six clinical facilitators.

Methods: This study is a follow-up of an experimental study on the Virtual Counseling Application Using Artificial Intelligence (VCAAI). The study took place from the academic year 2017/2018 ended in November 2019. Focus group discussions and individual interviews were conducted. All interviews and focus group discussions were audiotaped, transcribed verbatim, and analyzed using thematic analysis.

Results: Two overarching themes (students' virtual patient user experience and clinical facilitators' evaluations of students' clinical communication skills) comprising six themes were generated. Themes under students' user experience included: 1) attitudes toward virtual patient training, 2) virtual patient's role in student development, and 3) enhanced features and implementation suggestions. Themes under clinical facilitators' evaluations included: 1) insights on students' communication skills and 2) approaches to improve communication skills. An overlapping theme titled 'value of technology in teaching communication' comprised of mutual feedback from both students and clinical facilitators. Early implementation, continued accessibility, enhancing realism and technological improvements to the VCAAI were listed as key areas for program improvement, while increased situational sensitivity and language training are recommended to further enhance students' communication skills.

Conclusion: The mixed attitudes toward virtual patient interactions and recognitions of the benefits of virtual patient simulations suggest the potential effectiveness of the use of virtual patients in teaching effective nursing communication skills. However, the lack of authenticity and other limitations need to be addressed before official implementations of such trainings with virtual patients to undergraduate nursing curricula.

Keywords: Clinical facilitators; Nursing undergraduates; Simulations; Virtual patients.