Chromosomal insertions are thought to be rare structural rearrangements. The current understanding of the underlying mechanisms of their origin is still limited. In this study, we sequenced 16 cases with apparent simple insertions previously identified by karyotyping and/or chromosomal microarray analysis. Using mate-pair genome sequencing (GS), we identified all 16 insertions and revised previously designated karyotypes in 75.0% (12/16) of the cases. Additional cryptic rearrangements were identified in 68.8% of the cases (11/16). The incidence of additional cryptic rearrangements in chromosomal insertions was significantly higher compared to balanced translocations and inversions reported in other studies by GS. We characterized and classified the cryptic insertion rearrangements into four groups, which were not mutually exclusive: (1) insertion segments were fragmented and their subsegments rearranged and clustered at the insertion site (10/16, 62.5%); (2) one or more cryptic subsegments were not inserted into the insertion site (5/16, 31.3%); (3) segments of the acceptor chromosome were scattered and rejoined with the insertion segments (2/16, 12.5%); and (4) copy number gains were identified in the flanking regions of the insertion site (2/16, 12.5%). In addition to the observation of these chromothripsis- or chromoanasynthesis-like events, breakpoint sequence analysis revealed microhomology to be the predominant feature. However, no significant correlation was found between the number of cryptic rearrangements and the size of the insertion. Overall, our study provide molecular characterization of karyotypically apparent simple insertions, demonstrate previously underappreciated complexities, and evidence that chromosomal insertions are likely formed by nonhomologous end joining and/or microhomology-mediated replication-based DNA repair.