The CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) at metal electrodes is altered in the presence of pyridine and related species. Thick films of poly(4-vinylpyridine) on Au electrodes result in large current enhancements at low applied potentials but do not enhance CO2RR at these potentials. Surface-enhanced Raman spectroelectrochemistry can probe CO2-surface interactions and reveals that desorption of CO2 as bicarbonate is retarded in the presence of 4-PVP, with implications for ion-transport limitations in thick film CO2RR.