Inverse stochastic resonance comprises a nonlinear response of an oscillatory system to noise where the frequency of noise-perturbed oscillations becomes minimal at an intermediate noise level. We demonstrate two generic scenarios for inverse stochastic resonance by considering a paradigmatic model of two adaptively coupled stochastic active rotators whose local dynamics is close to a bifurcation threshold. In the first scenario, shown for the two rotators in the excitable regime, inverse stochastic resonance emerges due to a biased switching between the oscillatory and the quasi-stationary metastable states derived from the attractors of the noiseless system. In the second scenario, illustrated for the rotators in the oscillatory regime, inverse stochastic resonance arises due to a trapping effect associated with a noise-enhanced stability of an unstable fixed point. The details of the mechanisms behind the resonant effect are explained in terms of slow-fast analysis of the corresponding noiseless systems.