Vibrational sum-frequency generation (SFG) spectroscopy is used to determine the surface pKa of p-methyl benzoic acid (pMBA) at the air-water interface by monitoring the carbonyl and carboxylate stretching modes over the pH range of 2 to 12. The SFG intensities of pMBA and its conjugate base, p-methyl benzoate (pMBA-), exhibit an anomalously large enhancement over a narrow pH range (∼0.5) centered at pH 6.3 near the SFG-determined surface pKa, 5.9 ± 0.1. The increase in the surface pKa relative to the bulk value of 4.34 is consistent with the trend previously observed for long chain carboxylic acids in which the surface pKa is higher than the bulk solution pKa. SFG polarization studies help distinguish the orientation and number density contributions to this observed anomalous surface phenomenon. The large SFG intensity increase is attributed to an increase in the pMBA and pMBA- surface concentrations in this narrow pH range due to a cooperative adsorption effect between pMBA and pMBA-. This cooperativity is manifested only on the 2D air-water interface, where the interactions between the acid and base are not as dielectrically screened as in the aqueous bulk phase. Surface effects are critical to understanding and controlling the reactivity, solubility, and behavior of organic acids at interfaces and can have an impact on biomedical applications.