Morphological, spectroscopic, and scattering studies of the self-assembly and aggregation of mixtures of [RF]4 and P[RF]4 peptides (where R = arginine; F = phenylalanine; P = proline), in solution and as hydrogels, were performed to obtain information about polymorphism. CD data confirmed a β-sheet secondary structure in aqueous solution, and TEM images revealed nanofibers with diameters of ∼10 nm and micrometer lengths. SAXS curves were fitted using a mass fractal-component and a long cylinder shell form factor for the liquid samples, and only a long cylinder shell form factor for the gels. Increasing the P[RF]4 content in the systems leads to a reduction in cylinder radius and core scattering density, suggesting an increase in packing of the peptide molecules; however, the opposite effect is observed for the gels, where the scattering density is higher in the shell for the systems containing higher P[RF]4 content. These compounds show potential as catalysts in the asymmetric aldol reactions, with cyclohexanone and p-nitrobenzaldehyde in aqueous media. A moderate conversion (36.9%) and a good stereoselectivity (69:31) were observed for the system containing only [RF]4. With increasing P[RF]4 content, a considerable decrease of the conversion was observed, suggesting differences in the self-assembly and packing factor. Rheological measurements were performed to determine the shear moduli for the soft gels.