The budding yeast v-SNARE, Snc1, mediates fusion of exocytic vesicles to the plasma membrane (PM) and is subsequently recycled back to the Golgi. Postendocytic recycling of Snc1 requires a phospholipid flippase (Drs2-Cdc50), an F-box protein (Rcy1), a sorting nexin (Snx4-Atg20), and the COPI coat complex. A portion of the endocytic tracer FM4-64 is also recycled back to the PM after internalization. However, the relationship between Snx4, Drs2, Rcy1, and COPI in recycling Snc1 or FM4-64 is unclear. Here we show that rcy1∆ and drs2∆ single mutants, or a COPI mutant deficient in ubiquitin binding, display a defect in recycling FM4-64 while snx4∆ cells recycle FM4-64 normally. The addition of latrunculin A to acutely inhibit endocytosis shows that rcy1∆ and snx4∆ single mutants retain the ability to recycle Snc1, but a snx4∆rcy1∆ mutant substantially blocks export. Additional deletion of a retromer subunit completely eliminates recycling of Snc1 in the triple mutant (snx4∆rcy1∆vps35∆). A minor role for retromer in Snc1 recycling can also be observed in single and double mutants harboring vps35∆. These data support the existence of three distinct and parallel recycling pathways mediated by Drs2/Rcy1/COPI, Snx4-Atg20, and retromer that retrieve an exocytic v-SNARE from the endocytic pathway to the Golgi.