Introduction and Objectives: To determine the optimal guidewire for bypassing an impacted ureteral stone. Materials and Methods: Three different benchtop models of varying impaction (300, 362, and 444 mm Hg pressure) were used to compare the ability of 13 different guidewires to bypass an impacted ureteral stone. In the first and second models, we recorded the maximum force required to bypass the stone. In the first model (300 mm Hg) 10 new wires for each of the 13 types were advanced past a ureteral stone using a series 5 digital force gauge. In the second model (362 mm Hg), the top 5 performing guidewires were similarly tested. In the third model (444 mm Hg), 5 attending urologists and 5 urology residents (blinded to wire type) compared the 13 guidewires and rated the wire performance using a Likert scale. Statistical analysis was performed with analysis of variance and the chi-square test. Results: In the first model, there was a significant difference between wires (p < 0.001) with the lowest mean force to bypass a stone seen in the Glidewire (0.117 ± 0.02 lbs) and HiWire (0.130 ± 0.01 lbs). Of the five wires tested in the second model, the Glidewire (0.24 ± 0.09 lbs) and UltraTrack (0.40 ± 0.35 lbs) both required less force than the other three wires (p = 0.018). In the third model, only two wires (Roadrunner and Glidewire) bypassed the impacted stone in 100% of trials. When comparing standard, hybrid, and hydrophilic wires, the hydrophilic had the highest success rate (standard = 0%, hybrid = 36.67%, and hydrophilic = 70.67%; p = 0.000) and Likert score (standard = 1.03, hybrid = 2.38, and hydrophilic = 3.24; p = 0.000). Hydrophilic wires required the least time to bypass the stone (hybrid = 82.81 seconds vs hydrophilic = 45.37 seconds, p = 0.000). Conclusions: In this benchtop study, standard wires performed poorly and hybrid wires were not as effective as hydrophilic wires. The Glidewire required the least force, the shortest insertion time, and had the highest surgeon satisfaction rating.
Keywords: guidewires; ureteral calculi; ureteral obstruction.