Introduction: Heart failure remains one of the largest clinical challenges in the United States. Researchers have continually searched for more effective heart failure treatments that target the cardiac sarcomere but have found few successes despite numerous expensive cardiovascular clinical trials. Among many reasons, the high failure rate of cardiovascular clinical trials may be partly due to incomplete characterization of a drug candidate's complex interaction with cardiac physiology.Areas covered: In this review, the authors address the issue of preclinical cardiovascular studies of sarcomere-targeting heart failure therapies. The authors consider inherent tradeoffs made between mechanistic transparency and physiological fidelity for several relevant preclinical techniques at the atomic, molecular, heart muscle fiber, whole heart, and whole-organism levels. Thus, the authors suggest a comprehensive, bottom-up approach to preclinical cardiovascular studies that fosters scientific rigor and hypothesis-driven drug discovery.Expert opinion: In the authors' opinion, the implementation of hypothesis-driven drug discovery practices, such as the bottom-up approach to preclinical cardiovascular studies, will be imperative for the successful development of novel heart failure treatments. However, additional changes to clinical definitions of heart failure and current drug discovery culture must accompany the bottom-up approach to maximize the effectiveness of hypothesis-driven drug discovery.
Keywords: Drug discovery; biophysical measurements; cross-bridge kinetics; heart failure; in vivo function; sarcomere-based therapy; solution-based chemistry.