Y2MnGa(Mn4-xGax)O12 solid solutions were synthesized at high pressure of ∼6 GPa and high temperature of ∼1570 K for the 0 ≤ x ≤ 3 compositional range. Synchrotron X-ray and neutron powder diffraction were used to study the crystal structures and cation distributions. These solutions adopt the parent structure of the A-site columnar-ordered quadruple perovskite family with space group P42/nmc (No. 137). They have lattice parameters of a = 7.36095 Å and c = 7.753 84 Å (x = 0), a = 7.361 68 Å and c = 7.716 16 Å (x = 1), a = 7.360 34 Å and c = 7.67142 Å (x = 2), and a = 7.363 93 Å and c = 7.616 85 Å (x = 3) at room temperature. The x = 0 sample has a cation distribution of [Y3+2]A[Mn3+]A'[Ga3+0.68Mn2+0.32]A″[Mn3.68Ga0.32]BO12 with a preferred localization of Ga3+ in the tetrahedral A″ site and with a small amount of Ga3+ in the octahedral B site. A complete triple A-site order, [Y3+2]A[Mn3+]A'[Ga3+]A″[Mn3+4-xGa3+x]BO12, is realized for x ≥ 1. All samples demonstrate spin-glass-like magnetic properties, and the absence of a long-range magnetic order at the ground state at 1.5 K was confirmed by neutron diffraction for the x = 1 sample. First-principles calculations indicated the spin-glass-like magnetic ordering is derived from the Ga substitution to the B sites and gave evidence that the ideal cation distribution could produce robust ferromagnetism in this family of perovskites.