Wavefront sensing with a thin diffuser has emerged as a potential low-cost alternative to a lenslet array for aberrometry. Here we show that displacement of caustic patterns can be tracked for estimating wavefront gradient in a diffuser wavefront sensor (DWFS), enabling large dynamic-range wavefront measurements with sufficient accuracy for eyeglass prescription measurements. We compare the dynamic range, repeatability, precision, and number of resolvable prescriptions of a DWFS to a Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensor (SHWFS) for autorefraction measurement. We induce spherical and cylindrical errors in a model eye and use a multi-level Demon's non-rigid registration algorithm to estimate caustic displacements relative to an emmetropic model eye. When compared to spherical error measurements with the SHWFS using a laser diode with a laser speckle reducer, the DWFS demonstrates a ∼5-fold improvement in dynamic range (-4.0 to +4.5 D vs. -22.0 to +19.5 D) with less than half the reduction in resolution (0.072 vs. 0.116 D), enabling a ∼3-fold increase in the number of resolvable prescriptions (118 vs. 358). In addition to being lower-cost, the unique, non-periodic nature of the caustic pattern formed by a diffuser enables a larger dynamic range of aberration measurements compared to a lenslet array.