Frameshift mutations in the calreticulin (CALR) gene are present in 30% of essential thrombocythemia and myelofibrosis patients. The two most frequent mutations are CALR del52 (type 1, approximately 60%) and CALR ins5 (type 2, around 30%), but many other rarer mutations exist accounting each for less than 2% of all CALR mutations. Most of them are structurally classified as type 1-like and type 2-like CALR mutations according to the absence or presence of a residual wild-type calcium-binding motif and the modification of the alpha-helix structure. Yet, several key questions remain unanswered, especially the reason of such low frequencies of these other mutations. In an attempt to investigate specific pathogenic differences between type 1-like and type 2-like CALR mutations and del52 and ins5, we modeled two type 1-like (del34 and del46) and one type 2-like (del19) mutations in cell lines and in mice. All CALR mutants constitutively activate JAK2 and STAT5/3/1 in a similar way in the presence of the thrombopoietin receptor (MPL) and induced cytokine-independent cell growth but to a lesser extent with rare mutants over time. This correlates with reduced expression levels of rare CALR mutants compared to del52 and ins5. Lethally irradiated mice that were engrafted with bone marrow transduced with the different CALR mutations developed thrombocytosis, but to a much lesser extent with ins5 and the type 2-like CALR mutation. In contrast to type 2-like mice, type 1-like mice developed marked myelofibrosis and splenomegaly 10 months after engraftment. Similar to del52, type 1-like CALR mutations induced an expansion at an early stage of hematopoiesis compared to ins5 and type 2-like mutation. Thus, type 1-like and type 2-like CALR mutants structurally and functionally resemble del52 and ins5 mutants, respectively.