In vitro inhibition of avian pathogenic Enterococcus cecorum isolates by probiotic Bacillus strains

Abstract

Enterococcus cecorum is a commensal bacteria and opportunistic pathogen that can cause outbreaks of Enterococcal spondylitis ("kinky back") in poultry, with a growing concern worldwide. Numerous Bacillus-based probiotic strains are commercially available with proven effects in supporting gut health and growth performance, but efficacy against pathogenic E. cecorum is unknown. This study compared the in vitro inhibitory potential of cell-free supernatants (CFSs) of 18 Bacillus strains (14 commercial probiotic strains, 1 internal negative control and 3 type strains) on the growth of 9 clinical E. cecorum isolates. Standardized biomass cultures of live Bacillus were harvested and filtered to obtain CFSs. Inhibitory potential against E. cecorum isolates was assessed via a microdilution assay in which the final pathogen concentration was ∼ 104 CFU/mL. Absorbance (OD) was measured every 15 min for 15 h and used to calculate percentage growth inhibition at an OD equivalent to 0.4 in the positive control (PC) (pathogen but no CFS), and growth delay vs. PC. Growth kinetic responses of pathogen isolate-Bacillus strain combinations ranged from total pathogen inhibition to partial inhibition, lag in growth, no effect, or increased growth vs. PC. Percentage inhibition of individual isolates varied markedly among Bacillus strains, from 100% to -100% (growth promotion as recorded for the type strain) (B. amyloliquefaciens DSM7T). Five B. amyloliquefaciens CFSs produced higher average inhibition rates (>75%) than 2 out of 3 Bacillus licheniformis CFSs (-2.5, and -8.39% vs. PC, respectively) and 1 out of 2 Bacillus subtilis CFSs (7.3% vs. PC) (P < 0.05). Commercial strain 3AP4 exhibited the highest average percentage inhibition vs. PC (85.0% ± 7.9) and the most consistent inhibitory effect across pathogen isolates. The findings indicate that some commercially available poultry probiotic Bacillus strains are effective at inhibiting pathogenic E. cecorum in vitro, but effects are highly strain and pathogen isolate-dependent. Further work is required to confirm effects in vivo and isolate the inhibitory substances.

Keywords: Bacillus; Enterococcus cecorum; pathogen inhibition; probiotic.