Sports and the human brain: an evolutionary perspective

Abstract

An evolutionary perspective helps explain a conundrum faced by sports neurologists: why is the human brain dependent on physical activity to function optimally, yet simultaneously susceptible to harm from particular types of athletics? For millions of years, human bodies and brains co-evolved to meet the physical and cognitive demands of the uniquely human subsistence strategy of hunting and gathering. Natural selection favored bodies with adaptations for endurance-based physical activity patterns, whereas brains were selected to be big and powerful to navigate the complex cultural and ecologic landscapes of hunter-gatherers. Human brains require physical activity to function optimally because their physiology evolved among individuals who were rarely able to avoid regular physical activity. Moreover, because energy from food was limited, human brains, like most energetically costly physiologic systems, evolved to require stimuli from physical activity to adjust capacity to demand. Consequently, human brains are poorly adapted to excessive physical inactivity. In addition, while brain enlargement during human evolution was vital to successful hunting and gathering, it came at the cost of a decreased ability to withstand brain accelerations and decelerations, which commonly occur during contact/collision sports.

Keywords: Homo; brain evolution; chronic traumatic encephalopathy; concussion; contact sports; encephalization; endurance; evolutionary medicine; football; human evolution; hunter-gatherer; mismatch disease; physical activity; subconcussive.