The performance of devices containing colloidal quantum dot (CQD) films is strongly dependent on the surface chemistry of the CQDs they contain. Multistep surface treatments, which combine two or more strategies, are important for creating films with high carrier mobility that are well passivated against trap states and oxidation. Here, we examine the effect of a number of these surface treatments on PbS CQD films, including cation exchange to form PbS/CdS core/shell CQDs, and solid-state ligand-exchange treatments with Cl, Br, I, and 1,2-ethanedithiol (EDT) ligands. Using laboratory-based and synchrotron-radiation-excited X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), we examine the compositions of the surface layer before and after treatment, and correlate this with the performance data and stability in air. We find that halide ion treatments may etch the CQD surfaces, with detrimental effects on the air stability and solar cell device performance caused by a reduction in the proportion of passivated surface sites. We show that films made up of PbS/CdS CQDs are particularly prone to this, suggesting Cd is more easily etched from the surface than Pb. However, by choosing a less aggressive ligand treatment, a good coverage of passivators on the surface can be achieved. We show that halide anions bind preferentially to surface Pb (rather than Cd). By isolating the part of XPS signal originating from the topmost surface layer of the CQD, we show that air stability is correlated with the total number of passivating agents (halide + EDT + Cd) at the surface.