Microbial iron(III) reduction can have a profound effect on the fate of contaminants in natural and engineered environments. Different mechanisms of extracellular electron transport are used by Geobacter and Shewanella spp. to reduce insoluble Fe(III) minerals. Here we prepared a thin film of iron(III)-(oxyhydr)oxide doped with arsenic, and allowed the mineral coating to be colonised by Geobacter sulfurreducens or Shewanella ANA3 labelled with 13C from organic electron donors. This preserved the spatial relationship between metabolically active Fe(III)-reducing bacteria and the iron(III)-(oxyhydr)oxide that they were respiring. NanoSIMS imaging showed cells of G. sulfurreducens were co-located with the iron(III)-(oxyhydr)oxide surface and were significantly more 13C-enriched compared to cells located away from the mineral, consistent with Geobacter species requiring direct contact with an extracellular electron acceptor to support growth. There was no such intimate relationship between 13C-enriched S. ANA3 and the iron(III)-(oxyhydr)oxide surface, consistent with Shewanella species being able to reduce Fe(III) indirectly using a secreted endogenous mediator. Some differences were observed in the amount of As relative to Fe in the local environment of G. sulfurreducens compared to the bulk mineral, highlighting the usefulness of this type of analysis for probing interactions between microbial cells and Fe-trace metal distributions in biogeochemical experiments.