Hyoscyamine 6β-hydroxylase (H6H) is an α-ketoglutarate dependent mononuclear nonheme iron enzyme that catalyzes C6-hydroxylation of hyoscyamine and oxidative cyclization of the resulting product to give the oxirane natural product scopolamine. Herein, the chemistry of H6H is investigated using hyoscyamine derivatives with modifications at the C6 or C7 position as well as substrate analogues possessing a 9-azabicyclo[3.3.1]nonane core. Results indicate that hydroxyl rebound is unlikely to take place during the cyclization reaction and that the hydroxylase versus oxidative cyclase activity of H6H is correlated with the presence of an exo-hydroxy group having syn-periplanar geometry with respect to the adjacent H atom to be abstracted.