We use experiment and computational modeling to understand the defect structure and director configuration in a nematic liquid crystal capillary bridge confined between two parallel plates. We find that tuning of the aspect ratio of the bridge drives a transition between a ring defect and a point defect. This transition exhibits hysteresis, due to the metastability of the point-defect structure. In addition, we see that the shape of the capillary-bridge surface determines whether the defect is hyperbolic or radial, with waistlike bridges containing hyperbolic defects and barrel-like bridges containing radial defects.