Musculoskeletal trauma and pain can sensitize central pain mechanisms, but whether these normalize on recovery is unknown. This study compared the extent of pain referral in individuals recovered from a musculoskeletal trauma and healthy controls. Twenty pain-free participants recovered from a shoulder fracture and 20 age-/sex-matched controls participated in 2 experimental sessions (day-0 and day-1) separated by 24 hours. On both days, pressure pain thresholds were measured bilaterally at infraspinatus, supraspinatus, trapezius, and gastrocnemius muscles. Referred pain towards the shoulder region was induced by a 60-second pressure stimulation (pressure pain threshold + 20%) at the infraspinatus muscle and recorded on an electronic body chart. After day-0 assessments, delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS) was induced to challenge the pain systems by exercising the external rotators of the recovered/dominant shoulder. The size of pressure-induced pain referral on day-0 did not differ between groups, although there was a tendency for a smaller referred pain area in recovered group. Pressure pain thresholds at the infraspinatus muscle on the DOMS side were reduced on day-1 in both groups (P = 0.03). An expansion of pressure-induced pain referral was found in both groups following the DOMS protocol on day-1 (P = 0.05) with a relatively larger expansion (P = 0.05) and higher frequency of pain in the shoulder (P = 0.04) in the recovered pain group. After complete recovery and absence of pain symptoms after a fracture, central pain mechanisms seem to normalize in the region of the trauma after recovery but when sensitized a heightened response can emerge. Such mechanisms could be important for recurrence of pain conditions.