An enoylreductase (ER) domain of a polyketide synthase module recruiting a methylmalonate extender unit sets the C2 methyl branch to either the S or R configuration during processing of a polyketide intermediate carried by an acyl carrier protein (ACP) domain. In the present study, pantetheine- and ACP-bound trans-2-methylcrotonyl substrate surrogates were used to scrutinize the stereospecificity of the ER domains. The pantetheine-bound thioester was reduced to mixtures of both 2 R and 2 S products, whereas the expected 2 S epimer was almost exclusively generated when the cognate ACP-bound substrate surrogate was utilized. The analogous incubation of an ER with the substrate surrogate carried by a noncognate ACP significantly increased the generation of the unexpected 2 R epimer, highlighting the dependence of stereospecificity on proper protein-protein interactions between ER and ACP domains. The ER mutant assays revealed the involvement of the conserved tyrosine and lysine in stereocontrol. Taken together, these results expand the current understanding of the ER stereochemistry and help in the engineering of modular PKSs.