The ligand 2,2'-bipyridine (bpy) can support metal centers in low formal oxidation states by delocalization of electron density into its π-system. We show that, in a model rhodium complex supported by the pentamethylcyclopentadienyl ligand (Cp*), the analogous dimethyldipyridylmethane ligand (Me2dpma) enforces a bpy-like coordination environment but disrupts the inter-ring conjugation responsible for charge delocalization upon metal reduction. As a result, reduction proceeds in discrete one-electron steps (Rh(iii) to Rh(ii) to Rh(i)), contrasting with the 2e- chemistry engendered by bpy. Upon reduction to Rh(i), the Me2dpma ligand rearranges to activate strong π-backbonding via facial coordination of one pyridine motif. Structural and spectroscopic studies confirm stabilization of the Rh(i) center in this compound, revealing a mode of metal-ligand cooperation that represents a useful counterpoint to charge delocalization in conjugated poly(pyridyl) ligands.