Perspectives of Immigrant Women on the Gender of Provider During Childbirth

Abstract

Objective: This study sought to gain an understanding of the importance and effect of provider gender for immigrant women accessing obstetrical care.

Methods: A focused ethnography was conducted using purposive sampling of 38 immigrant women from one hospital in Edmonton, Alberta. Data collection consisted of semistructured interviews conducted antenatally (n = 38); an attempt was made to conduct interviews postpartum (n = 21), and intrapartum observations were made (n = 17). Interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim. Data were managed using qualitative data analysis software and analyzed through thematic analysis.

Results: Study participants came from varied educational and ethnic backgrounds (predominately North/East African, Middle Eastern, and South Asian), but most were Muslim (n = 30) and married (n = 36), with a mean age of 27.7. All of the women stated that they preferred a female provider, which they explained in terms of the high value they placed on modesty, often as part of the Muslim faith. The women deemed provider competency and having safe childbirth more important, however, and said that they would accept intrapartum care from a male provider. A small minority of the women reported experiencing psychological stress as a consequence of having received care from a male provider.

Conclusion: As a whole, our study population accepted care from male providers, yet for some women this compromise came at a price, and a small minority of women perceived it as profoundly detrimental. There is a need to identify those women for whom gender of provider is a substantial barrier, so that optimal support can be provided.

Keywords: Emigrants; immigrants,patient preference; physicians; women.