We present a case of a diverticulum of the sigmoid colon with intense prostate-specific membrane antigen (PSMA) activity on Ga-PSMA PET/CT. CT scan and colonoscopy showed no signs of inflammation or malignancy. This case presents an addition to the collection of benign pitfalls when reporting PSMA PET/CT; however, a Ga-PSMA up-taking focus in the colon should always cause further examination, as malignant etiology must be ruled out.