Using halogen-specific Connolly type molecular surfaces, we herein invented a new type of surface-based interaction analysis employed for the study of halogen bonding toward model systems of biologically relevant carboxylates (ASP/GLU) and carboxamides (ASN/GLN). Database mining and statistical assessment of the PDB revealed that such interactions are widely underrepresented at the moment. We observed important distance-dependent adaptions of the binding modes of halobenzenes from a preferential oxygen-directed to a bifurcated interaction geometry of the carboxylate. In addition, halogen···π contacts perpendicular to the nitrogen atom of the carboxamide become increasingly important for the lighter halogens. Our analysis on a MP2/TZVPP level of theory is backed by CCSD(T)/CBS reference calculations. To put the vast interaction energies into perspective, we also performed COSMO-RS calculations of the solvation free energy. Facilitating the visualization of our results mapped onto any binding site of choice, we aim to inspire more design studies showcasing these underrepresented interactions.