Comparison of three-dimensional analysis and stereological techniques for quantifying lithium-ion battery electrode microstructures

J Microsc. 2016 Sep;263(3):280-92. doi: 10.1111/jmi.12389. Epub 2016 Mar 21.

Abstract

Lithium-ion battery performance is intrinsically linked to electrode microstructure. Quantitative measurement of key structural parameters of lithium-ion battery electrode microstructures will enable optimization as well as motivate systematic numerical studies for the improvement of battery performance. With the rapid development of 3-D imaging techniques, quantitative assessment of 3-D microstructures from 2-D image sections by stereological methods appears outmoded; however, in spite of the proliferation of tomographic imaging techniques, it remains significantly easier to obtain two-dimensional (2-D) data sets. In this study, stereological prediction and three-dimensional (3-D) analysis techniques for quantitative assessment of key geometric parameters for characterizing battery electrode microstructures are examined and compared. Lithium-ion battery electrodes were imaged using synchrotron-based X-ray tomographic microscopy. For each electrode sample investigated, stereological analysis was performed on reconstructed 2-D image sections generated from tomographic imaging, whereas direct 3-D analysis was performed on reconstructed image volumes. The analysis showed that geometric parameter estimation using 2-D image sections is bound to be associated with ambiguity and that volume-based 3-D characterization of nonconvex, irregular and interconnected particles can be used to more accurately quantify spatially-dependent parameters, such as tortuosity and pore-phase connectivity.

There is a strong link between electrode microstructure and battery performance within lithium‐ion batteries. Quantitatively assessing these inherently 3‐D electrode microstructures will help provide data for numerical studies to help improve battery performance. With the rapid development of 3‐D imaging techniques, quantitative assessment of 3‐D microstructures from 2‐D image sections by stereological methods appears outmoded; however, in spite of the proliferation of tomographic imaging techniques, it remains significantly easier to obtain 2‐D data sets. In this study, stereological prediction and 3‐D analysis techniques for quantitative assessment of key geometric parameters for characterizing battery electrode microstructures are examined and compared. The analysis showed that geometric parameter estimation using 2‐D image sections is bound to be associated with ambiguity and that volume‐based 3‐D characterization of nonconvex, irregular and interconnected particles can be used to more accurately quantify spatially‐dependent parameters, such as tortuosity and pore‐phase connectivity.

Keywords: 3-D image analysis; Image quantification; X-ray tomography; lithium-ion battery; microstructural characterization; stereology.

Publication types

  • Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't