Rationale: Despite reports of unreliability, the QuantiFERON-TB interferon-γ release assay is increasingly used for the annual screening of individuals at risk for latent tuberculosis. Continued use of the QuantiFERON-TB assay suggests the need for more definitive evidence of its reproducibility and accuracy.
Objectives: To examine reproducibility and the accumulation of false-positive test results when the QuantiFERON-TB is repeated annually and to examine the validity of confirming positive test results with the performance of a second QuantiFERON-TB.
Methods: We performed a retrospective, longitudinal evaluation of results from serial screening of a cohort of emergency responders from 2001 to 2013.
Measurements and main results: Results of tuberculin tests and QuantiFERON-TB tests performed annually as part of a mandated first responder examination were retroactively reviewed. In this population, positive results occurred in new individuals each year. QuantiFERON-TB results were positive in 80 of 557 tuberculin test-negative individuals examined annually for a maximum of 7 years. Only 10 individuals with initially positive results remained positive when the test was repeated the next year, and 9 of these 10 were QuantiFERON-TB-negative within 3 years. The number of individuals with a positive result increased annually, and, after 7 years, 32 (27.4%) of 117 people had a positive result.
Conclusions: When viewed in the context of the extensive literature documenting unreliable QuantiFERON-TB test performance, our findings of frequent, cumulative, sporadic, and irreproducible positive results support discontinuing the use of the QuantiFERON-TB assay for the diagnosis of latent tuberculosis in low-risk populations.
Keywords: interferon-γ release tests; latent tuberculosis; reproducibility of results; tuberculin; tuberculin test.