The fungus Paecilomyces lilacinus produces leucinostatins—peptaibiotics that exert a range of biological activities including antimalarial, antiviral, antitumor and phytotoxicity. In this paper, we developed an analytical method employing LC-MS/MS in the precursor ion and product ion scan modes to elucidate five new leucinostatins. Direct Infusion (DI-MS) helped to identify the most abundant leucinostatins: F, D B2, S, A and K. MS/MS analysis using a triple quadrupole operating at different scan modes is a versatile tool to study natural products, especially peptaibiotics. Although DI-MS full-scan analysis is rapid and sensitive, it cannot distinguish between peptide isomers. On the other hand, LC-MS/MS operated in the precursor ion and product ion modes is time consuming, but allows identifying the structure of isomers or isobar in crude extracts.