A radiological concern for workers at heavy water reactor nuclear facilities is the hazard presented by tritium (H) and C. Radioactive methane is one of many potential H and C containing chemicals to which Nuclear Energy Workers (NEWs) may be exposed. Current dosimetric models for H- and C-methane, recommended by the International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP), are based on the assumption that 1% of methane is absorbed following its inhalation. Of this 1%, all H is converted immediately to tritiated water and C is converted immediately to CO2 (50%) and organically bound carbon (50%). In the study, rats were exposed to methane standards (H-methane and C-methane) mixed with breathing air to give a final concentration of 0.27% methane and resulting in final activity concentrations of 4.2 GBq m and 0.88 GBq m for H and C, respectively. This corresponds to exposure estimates of 580 kBq g and 120 kBq g. Simultaneous exposure to H- and C-methane allowed for the direct comparison of the retention of these radionuclides and removed uncertainties concerning their relative uptake and retention. The results demonstrate that the total methane uptake from the inhaled dose was threefold less than the 1% methane uptake predicted by the ICRP dosimetric models for H- and C-methane, with the H concentration being substantially higher than anticipated in the liver. This study provided data suggesting that current ICRP dosimetric methane models overestimate the fraction of H- and C-methane that is absorbed following inhalation and assisted in providing information to better understand the metabolism of inhaled H and C radiolabeled methane.