Translating removal efficiencies into operational performance indices of wastewater treatment plants

Catarina Silva; Sílvia Quadros; Pedro Ramalho; Helena Alegre; Maria João Rosa

doi:10.1016/j.watres.2014.03.025

Translating removal efficiencies into operational performance indices of wastewater treatment plants

Water Res. 2014 Jun 15:57:202-14. doi: 10.1016/j.watres.2014.03.025. Epub 2014 Mar 25.

Authors

Catarina Silva¹, Sílvia Quadros², Pedro Ramalho¹, Helena Alegre¹, Maria João Rosa³

Affiliations

¹ Urban Water Division, Hydraulics and Environment Department, LNEC - National Civil Engineering Laboratory, Av. Brasil 101, 1700-066 Lisboa, Portugal.
² Climate, Meteorology and Global Change Group (C_CMMG, CITA-A), Agricultural Sciences Department, Azores University, Rua Capitão João D' Avila, 9700-042 Angra do Heroísmo, Portugal.
³ Urban Water Division, Hydraulics and Environment Department, LNEC - National Civil Engineering Laboratory, Av. Brasil 101, 1700-066 Lisboa, Portugal. Electronic address: mjrosa@lnec.pt.

PMID: 24721667
DOI: 10.1016/j.watres.2014.03.025

Abstract

Removal efficiencies are often used to assess the performance of a single or a group of unit operations/processes (UOPs) of a wastewater treatment plant (WWTP). However, depending on the influent concentration (Cin), the same efficiency of removal (Er) may be insufficient or excessive to achieve the UOP or WWTP effluent quality requirements, expressed by concentration limit values (LVs). This paper proposes performance indices (PXs), Er-based, as new metrics for benchmarking, i.e. for assessing and improving the performance of each UOP or treatment step and ultimately of the WWTP as a multi-barrier system, and comprehensively describes the stepwise method of translating Ers into PXs. PXs are dimensionless and vary between 0 and 300 to define three performance levels: unsatisfactory (0-100), acceptable (100-200) and good (200-300) performance. The method developed takes into consideration Cin and LV, and the reference values for judging the performance are given from Er-Cin typical ranges and Er vs. Cin model curves, LV based and field data based. The general equations of the Er model curves are derived. A set of six curves is calibrated for TSS (Total Suspended Solids) and COD (Chemical Oxygen Demand) removal by primary sedimentation and activated sludge systems (carbon or combined carbon and nutrients removal), using 5-year (2006-2010) field data from five Portuguese WWTPs. A statistical analysis of the PX results is additionally proposed to assess treatment reliability. The new method is applied in two WWTPs and the PX results are compared with those of conventional measures - Er and performance indicators (PIs). The results demonstrate that, whereas a simplistic Er-driven or PI-driven management of the WWTPs shows limitations, the developed PXs are adequate measures for benchmarking removal efficiencies towards WWTP reliability and sustainability.

Keywords: Model curves; Modeling; Performance indicators; Performance indices; Removal efficiencies; Wastewater treatment plants.

Publication types

Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't

MeSH terms

Biological Oxygen Demand Analysis
Charcoal / chemistry
Portugal
Reproducibility of Results
Sewage / chemistry
Waste Disposal, Fluid / methods*
Wastewater / analysis*
Water Purification / methods*

Substances

Sewage
Waste Water
Charcoal