The present work refers to the debate which took place in Italy in the final years of the nineteenth century in relation to mental health and lunatic asylums, from which emerged various innovative proposals for avoiding compulsory confinement in numerous cases. Some of them became part of new legislative regulations regarding asylums, but most were excluded. Today, a new historical interpretation allows us to grasp a connection between Law 180, dated 1978 and known as the "Basaglia Law" from the name of its promoter, and alternative proposals to asylum custody omitted from the 1904 law.
Keywords: Asylum; Curability; History of Psychiatry; Mental Health; Training..