High recurrence rate at 5-year followup in children after upper urinary tract stone surgery

Abstract

Purpose: Pediatric urolithiasis has been treated with shock wave lithotripsy, ureteroscopy and percutaneous nephrolithotomy with high success rates during short-term followup. We studied our success rate and modifiable risk factors in patients with at least 5 years of followup postoperatively.

Materials and methods: Retrospective chart review was performed for patients younger than 18 years who underwent upper tract stone surgery between 1999 and 2007, were stone-free afterward and had at least 5 years of followup. Recurrence rate, and anatomical and metabolic abnormalities were assessed.

Results: Of 60 eligible children 30 (33 kidneys) had at least 5 years of followup. Average patient age at surgery was 10 years, 17 patients were female and 20 kidneys had anatomical abnormalities. Overall recurrence rate at 5 years was 55% (95% CI 38%-70%). Ureteral stones had a lower recurrence rate than renal stones (5 of 19 and 13 of 14, respectively, p <0.001). Patients with abnormal anatomy had a 65% (95% CI 43%-82%) chance of recurrence within 5 years vs 38% (95% CI 18%-65%) in those with normal anatomy (p = 0.17). Of the 18 recurrences 10 required a second operation, 7 demonstrated abnormal anatomy and 14 involved calcium based stones. A 24-hour urine test in 13 children revealed 10 with hypercalciuria and 11 with hypocitraturia, with 9 patients exhibiting both conditions.

Conclusions: We found a high recurrence rate in children with stones requiring surgical intervention, particularly those with abnormal anatomy. This finding should be confirmed in a larger multicenter study of recurrence rates. In the meantime our results suggest a need for aggressive diagnosis and treatment of metabolic abnormalities.

Keywords: KUB; PCNL; SWL; URS; hypercalciuria; pediatrics; percutaneous nephrolithotomy; recurrence; shock wave lithotripsy; ureteroscopy; urolithiasis; x-ray of kidneys, ureters and bladder.