Insulin is an amyloid-forming polypeptide built of two disulfide-linked chains (A and B), both themselves amyloidogenic. An interesting property of insulin is that agitation strongly influences the course of its aggregation, resulting in characteristic chiral superstructures of amyloid fibrils. Here, we investigate the self-assembly of these superstructures by comparing the quiescent and vortex-assisted aggregation of insulin and its individual A and B chains in the presence or absence of reducing agent tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine (TCEP). Our study shows that only the B chain in the presence of TCEP is converted into aggregates with morphology (according to atomic force microscopy) and optical activity (manifested as an extrinsic Cotton effect induced in bound thioflavin T) characteristic of amyloid superstructures that are normally formed by insulin in the absence of TCEP. In contrast to more rigid B-peptide fibrils, elongated aggregates of the A peptide become amorphous upon agitation. Moreover, the aggregation of equimolar mixture of both peptides does not produce highly ordered entities. Our results suggest that the dynamics of the B chain are the driving force for the assembly of superstructures, with the A chain being complicit as long as its own dynamics are controlled by the firm attachment to the B chain provided by the intact covalent structure of insulin.