Reproducibility and reliability of semen analysis in youths at risk for infertility

Abstract

Purpose: There are few normative data on semen analyses in youths at risk for but not presenting with infertility. Standard practice among infertility specialists includes evaluation of 2 separate semen samples, given the degree of within subject variability. We hypothesized that males transitioning from pediatric to adult care who are at risk for infertility would similarly have this variability.

Materials and methods: We retrospectively reviewed patients with a history of cryptorchidism or varicocele who submitted 2 semen samples for evaluation of fertility potential. The within subject coefficient of variation and intraclass correlation coefficient were calculated for each semen parameter to evaluate reproducibility and reliability, respectively.

Results: A total of 79 subjects were studied. Mean ± SD age was 18.8 ± 1.2 years (range 17.8 to 24.7). The within subject coefficient of variation was high for each semen parameter, ranging from 36% for volume and motility to 82% for total motile count. Intraclass correlation coefficient for a single semen analysis ranged from 0.55 for motility to 0.88 for total count. Intraclass correlation coefficient for total motile count was 0.78 (95% CI 0.67-0.85), consistent with substantial reliability.

Conclusions: Although we observed within patient variability of individual semen analysis parameters, overall there was substantial agreement between consecutive semen analyses in this population at risk for infertility, particularly regarding total motile count, which is the most important determinant of fertility from a semen analysis. Therefore, it is possible to appropriately classify some young men based on the result of a single measurement as they transition from pediatric to adult care.

Keywords: CV(w); ICC; SA; TMC; adolescent; intraclass correlation coefficient; reproducibility of results; semen analysis; total motile count; within subject coefficient of variation.