Chitin nanocrystals (ChN) have been shown to form stable Pickering emulsions. These oil-in-water emulsions were compared with conventional milk (whey protein isolate, WPI, and sodium caseinate, SCn) protein-stabilized emulsions in terms of their lipid digestion kinetics using an in vitro enzymatic protocol. The kinetics of fatty acid release were evaluated as well as the change in oil droplet size of the respective emulsions during lipid digestion. The interfacial pressure was measured by addition of the duodenal components using drop tensiometry and the electrical charge of the oil droplets was also assessed, in an attempt to relate the interfacial properties with the stability of the emulsions towards lipolysis. Lipid hydrolysis in the ChN-stabilized emulsion was appreciably slower and the plateau values of the total concentration of fatty acids released were much lower, compared to the WPI- and SCn-stabilized emulsions. Moreover, the ChN-stabilized emulsions were relatively stable to coalescence during lipid digestion, whereas the WPI- and SCn-stabilized emulsions exhibited a significant increase in their droplet size. On the other hand, no major differences were shown among the different emulsion samples in terms of their interfacial properties. The increased stability of the ChN-stabilized emulsions towards lipolysis could be attributed to several underlying mechanisms: (i) strong and irreversible adsorption of the chitin nanocrystals at the interface that might inhibit an extensive displacement of the solid particles by bile salts and lipase, (ii) network formation by the nanocrystals in the bulk (continuous) phase that may reduce lipid digestion kinetics, and (iii) the ability of chitin, and consequently of ChNs, to impair pancreatic lipase activity. The finding that ChNs can be used to impede lipid digestion may have important implications for the design and fabrication of structured emulsions with controlled lipid digestibility that could provide the basis for the development of novel products that may promote satiety, reduce caloric intake and combat obesity.