We report the first synthesis of sanguinamide B analogues. Substituting N-methylated (N-Me) amino acids, glycine (Gly), and L- or D-phenylalanine (Phe) into the backbone of sanguinamide B showed that only l- and d-Phe residues controlled the macrocycle conformation. The N-methylated and glycine analogues all had multiple conformations, whereas the L- and D-Phe derivatives only had a single conformation. Testing of all conformer analogues showed that inclusion of an L- or D-Phe was a superior design element than incorporating the N-Me moiety that is often utilized to control macrocyclic conformation. Finally, we show that there is an ideal Phe residue (in this case L-Phe) for generating compounds that have the greatest inhibitory effect on bacterial motility. Our data support the hypothesis that the macrocyclic conformation is dictated by the benzyl moiety requiring a "pseudoequatorial" position, and all other energy considerations are secondary.