In the classical mean-field description of the electric double layer, known as the Poisson-Boltzmann model, ions interact exclusively through their Coulomb potential. Ion specificity can arise through solvent-mediated, nonelectrostatic interactions between ions. We employ the Yukawa pair potential to model the presence of nonelectrostatic interactions. The combination of Yukawa and Coulomb potential on the mean-field level leads to the Poisson-Helmholtz-Boltzmann model, which employs two auxiliary potentials: one electrostatic and the other nonelectrostatic. In the present work we apply the Poisson-Helmholtz-Boltzmann model to ionic mixtures, consisting of monovalent cations and anions that exhibit different Yukawa interaction strengths. As a specific example we consider a single charged surface in contact with a symmetric monovalent electrolyte. From the minimization of the mean-field free energy we derive the Poisson-Boltzmann and Helmholtz-Boltzmann equations. These nonlinear equations can be solved analytically in the weak perturbation limit. This together with numerical solutions in the nonlinear regime suggests an intricate interplay between electrostatic and nonelectrostatic interactions. The structure and free energy of the electric double layer depends sensitively on the Yukawa interaction strengths between the different ion types and on the nonelectrostatic interactions of the mobile ions with the surface.