Is there a learning curve in foot and ankle surgery?

Abstract

Background: Previous studies of orthopaedic learning curves have largely described the introduction of new techniques to experienced consultants. End points have usually involved technical considerations. A paucity of evidence surrounds foot and ankle surgery. This study investigates the learning curve during a foot and ankle surgeon's first year, defined by functional outcome.

Methods: 150 patients underwent elective foot or ankle surgery during the whole period. Preoperative and 6 month postoperative functional scores were compared between the first and second 6 month groups.

Results: Functional improvement was greater, approaching significance, in the second group (p=0.0605). There was no difference for forefoot cases (p=0.345). Functional improvement was significantly greater in the second group with forefoot cases removed (p=0.0333).

Conclusions: A learning curve exists in the first year of practice of foot and ankle surgery, demonstrated by functional outcome. This is confined to ankle, hindfoot and midfoot, but not forefoot surgery.