Small interfering RNA (siRNA) has great therapeutic potential for the suppression of proteins associated with disease, but delivery methods are needed for improved efficacy. Here, we investigated the properties of micellar siRNA delivery vehicles prepared with poly(ethylene glycol)-block-poly(l-lysine) (PEG-b-PLL) comprising lysine amines modified to contain amidine and thiol functionality. Lysine modification was achieved using 2-iminothiolane (2-IT) [yielding PEG-b-PLL(N2IM-IM)] or dimethyl 3,3'-dithiobispropionimidate (DTBP) [yielding PEG-b-PLL(MPA)], with modifications aimed to impart disulfide cross-linking ability without compromising cationic charge. These two lysine modification reagents resulted in vastly different chemistry contained in the reacted block copolymer, which affected micelle formation behavior and stability along with in vitro and in vivo performance. Amidines formed with 2-IT were unstable and rearranged into a noncharged ring structure lacking free thiol functionality, whereas amidines generated with DTBP were stable. Micelles formed with siRNA and PEG-b-PLL(N2IM-IM) at higher molar ratios of polymer/siRNA, while PEG-b-PLL(MPA) produced micelles only near stoichiometric molar ratios. In vitro gene silencing was highest for PEG-b-PLL(MPA)/siRNA micelles, which were also more sensitive to disruption under disulfide-reducing conditions. Blood circulation was most improved for PEG-b-PLL(N2IM-IM)/siRNA micelles, with a circulation half-life 3× longer than naked siRNA. Both micelle formulations are promising for siRNA delivery applications in vitro and in vivo.