Cellular retinol-binding protein type I (CrbpI), encoded by Rpb1, serves as a chaperone of retinol homeostasis, but its physiological effects remain incompletely understood. We show here that the Rbp1(-/-) mouse has disrupted retinoid homeostasis in multiple tissues, with abnormally high 9-cis-retinoic acid (9cRA), a pancreas autacoid that attenuates glucose-stimulated insulin secretion. The Rbp1(-/-) pancreas has increased retinol and intense ectopic expression of Rpb2 mRNA, which encodes CrbpII: both would contribute to increased β-cell 9cRA biosynthesis. 9cRA in Rbp1(-/-) pancreas resists postprandial and glucose-induced decreases. Rbp1(-/-) mice have defective islet expression of genes involved in glucose sensing and insulin secretion, as well as islet α-cell infiltration, which contribute to reduced glucose-stimulated insulin secretion, high glucagon secretion, an abnormally high rate of gluconeogenesis, and hyperglycemia. A diet rich in vitamin A (as in a standard chow diet) increases pancreas 9cRA and impairs glucose tolerance. Crbp1 attenuates the negative impact of vitamin A (retinol) on glucose tolerance, regardless of the dietary retinol content. Rbp1(-/-) mice have an increased rate of fatty acid oxidation and resist obesity when fed a high-fat diet. Thus, glucose homeostasis and energy metabolism rely on Rbp1 expression and its moderation of pancreas retinol and of the autacoid 9cRA.