Molecular studies of apomictic plant species often detect more genotypic variation than predicted from their assumed reproductive mode. The two most commonly invoked mechanisms to explain these high levels of variation are recombination, via facultative sexuality, and mutation. The potential for sexual reproduction in the facultative apomict Hieracium pilosella (Asteraceae) was determined at three field sites by artificially pollinating with the closely related, but morphologically distinct, H. aurantiacum. The level of genotypic variation at the three sites was recorded using inter-simple sequence repeats (ISSRs). There was a significant, positive relationship between the measured potential for sexual reproduction and population genotypic variability, indicating that sex has played a role in the structuring of these populations; however, a causal relationship cannot be stated because of the use of regression. We also applied the recently developed method of compatibility analysis. Compatibility analysis can determine, using the occurrence of "character incompatibilities," whether patterns of variation observed in populations are most parsimoniously explained by mutation or recombination. Compatibility analysis also indicated that sexual reproduction had played a role in generating genotypic diversity in these populations. Combining these different types of data may give a greater understanding of the potential for the generation of genotypic diversity in facultative apomictic populations.