Aβ (amyloid β-peptide) is believed to cause AD (Alzheimer's disease). Aβ42 (Aβ comprising 42 amino acids) is substantially more neurotoxic than Aβ40 (Aβ comprising 40 amino acids), and this increased toxicity correlates with the existence of unique Aβ42 oligomers. Met³⁵ oxidation to sulfoxide or sulfone eliminates the differences in early oligomerization between Aβ40 and Aβ42. Met³⁵ oxidation to sulfoxide has been reported to decrease Aβ assembly kinetics and neurotoxicity, whereas oxidation to sulfone has rarely been studied. Based on these data, we expected that oxidation of Aβ to sulfone would also decrease its toxicity and assembly kinetics. To test this hypothesis, we compared systematically the effect of the wild-type, sulfoxide and sulfone forms of Aβ40 and Aβ42 on neuronal viability, dendritic spine morphology and macroscopic Ca²(+) currents in primary neurons, and correlated the data with assembly kinetics. Surprisingly, we found that, in contrast with Aβ-sulfoxide, Aβ-sulfone was as toxic and aggregated as fast, as wild-type Aβ. Thus, although Aβ-sulfone is similar to Aβ-sulfoxide in its dipole moment and oligomer size distribution, it behaves similarly to wild-type Aβ in its aggregation kinetics and neurotoxicity. These surprising data decouple the toxicity of oxidized Aβ from its initial oligomerization, and suggest that our current understanding of the effect of methionine oxidation in Aβ is limited.