Many genes have been listed as putatively essential for bacterial viability in the Database of Essential Genomes (DEG), although few have been experimentally validated. By prioritising targets according to the criteria suggested by the Research and Training in Tropical Diseases (TDR) Targets database, we have developed a modified down-selection tool to identify essential genes conserved across diverse genera. Using this approach we identified 52 proteins conserved to 7 or more of the 14 genomes in DEG. We confirmed the validity of the down-selection by attempting to make mutants of 8 of these targets in a model organism, Yersinia pseudotuberculosis, which is not closely related to any of the bacteria in DEG. Mutants were recovered for only one of the 8 targets, suggesting that the other 7 were essential in Y. pseudotuberculosis, an impressive success rate compared to other approaches of identification for such targets. Identification of essential proteins common in diverse bacterial genera can then be used to facilitate the selection of effective targets for novel broad-spectrum antibiotics.