The sequence segment 181-200 of the Torpedo nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) alpha subunit forms a binding site for alpha-bungarotoxin (alpha-BTX) [e.g., see Conti-Tronconi, B. M., Tang, F., Diethelm, B. M., Spencer, S. R., Reinhardt-Maelicke, S., & Maelicke, A. (1990) Biochemistry 29, 6221-6230]. Synthetic peptides corresponding to the homologous sequences of human, calf, mouse, chicken, frog, and cobra muscle nAChR alpha 1 subunits were tested for their ability to bind 125I-alpha-BTX, and differences in alpha-BTX affinity were determined by using solution (IC50S) and solid-phase (KdS) assays. Panels of overlapping peptides corresponding to the complete alpha 1 subunit of mouse and human were also tested for alpha-BTX binding, but other sequence segments forming the alpha-BTX site were not consistently detectable. The Torpedo alpha 1(181-200) and the homologous frog and chicken peptides bound alpha-BTX with higher affinity (KdS approximately 1-2 microM, IC50s approximately 1-2 microM) than the human and calf peptides (Kds approximately 3-5 microM, IC50s approximately 15 microM). The mouse peptide bound alpha-BTX weakly when attached to a solid support (Kd approximately 8 microM) but was effective in competing for 125I-alpha-BTX in solution (IC50 approximately 1 microM). The cobra nAChR alpha 1-subunit peptide did not detectably bind alpha-BTX in either assay. Amino acid substitutions were correlated with alpha-BTX binding activity peptides from different species. The role of a putative vicinal disulfide bound between Cys-192 and -193, relative to the Torpedo sequence, was determined by modifying the peptides with sulfhydryl reagents. Reduction and alkylation of the peptides decreased alpha-BTX binding, whereas oxidation of the peptides had little effect. Modifications of the cysteine/cystine residues of the cobra peptide failed to induce alpha-BTX binding activity. These results indicate that while the adjacent cysteines are likely to be involved in forming the toxin/alpha 1-subunit interface a vicinal disulfide bound was not required for alpha-BTX binding.